New York Distracted Driving Accident Lawyer’s Complete Guide: Proving Fault for Higher Compensation

What is Distracted Driving Under New York Law?

To understand whether your case qualifies as a distracted driving accident, you need to know how New York defines it.

Under New York Vehicle & Traffic Law §1225-c and §1225-d, it is illegal to:

• Hold a portable electronic device while driving
• Text, email, dial, or browse
• Use apps, read messages, or scroll while the vehicle is moving

New York recognizes three types of distraction:

1. ‍Visual Distraction: Eyes off the road (reading a message, checking GPS)
2. ‍Manual Distraction: Hands off the wheel (typing, holding a device)
3. ‍Cognitive Distraction: Mind off the task of driving (voice-to-text, absorbed in a call)

According to the Department of Motor Vehicles, NY, distracted driving is not completely restricted to the use of an electronic device.

Legally, any activity that diverts a driver’s eyes, hands, or attention from the road can qualify as distraction.

This includes:

• Eating or drinking
• Adjusting controls or GPS
• Reaching for objects
• Talking to passengers
• Looking at roadside events
• Handling items in the vehicle

If one of these activities contributed to your collision, the crash will be classified as a distracted driving accident. As a result, your potential compensation increases.

‍

The Gabriel Law Checklist for Injured Readers

Look out for these signs after a car crash in New York.‍

Many New Yorkers who contact Gabriel Law about a suspected distracted driving accident report at least one of the following:

• You saw the driver looking down before the collision.
• The car drifted out of its lane.
• It was a rideshare or delivery driver juggling apps.
• There were no skid marks, meaning the driver never braked.
• The driver’s story changed when the police arrived.
• A pedestrian or cyclist witnessed the crash.
• You noticed a cell phone lit up in the driver’s hand.
• The crash happened in stop-and-go Manhattan, Brooklyn, or Queens traffic.

If any of these signs match your experience, distraction could have been the cause.

The Role of No-Fault Insurance in Your Distracted Driving Accident

If you are a victim of a car accident in New York, then you get no-fault insurance by default for quick medical care and lost wages, regardless of who is at fault.

New York’s no-fault insurance means your own insurance pays first. This is your PIP (personal injury protection) coverage.

PIP covers:

• Medical treatment
• A portion of lost income
• Certain out-of-pocket expenses

However, do make a note that no-fault insurance does not cover pain and suffering.

If your accident is proven to be a distracted driving accident, then you have the ability to pursue additional damages for pain and suffering beyond what no-fault insurance covers.

Learn more about how the insurance claiming process works when your injury falls under the serious injury threshold and get help dealing with insurance from an experienced distracted driver accident lawyer in New York.

‍

Why a Distracted Driving Accident Increases Your Claim Value

Under New York negligence law, every driver owes a duty of care to operate their vehicle safely.

When a driver diverts their attention from the road (even for a moment), they breach that duty thus, causing legal liability.

Once liability is established, the at-fault driver becomes responsible for compensating you for:

• Medical expenses
• Lost wages
• Pain and suffering
• Long-term care
• Emotional distress
• Future losses

This is why distracted driving claims usually result in higher settlements:

Negligence → Liability → Higher Payout

Insurers know that once distraction is proven, their arguments weaken. Incidentally, this means your leverage increases and the settlement value rises.

‍

NYC Statistics for Higher Settlements in Distracted Driving Cases

Based on NYPD Motor Vehicle Collision Data:

• 5,322 distraction-related crashes occurred in early 2025.
• Distracted driving was the leading cause of NYC traffic accidents during Q1 2025.
• Over 115 deaths annually statewide are linked to distracted driving.

Despite robust safety programs like Vision Zero, traffic enforcement, and street redesigns, distracted driving remains a top cause of severe crashes.

A study published in the National Library of Medicine found that dialing a phone increases crash or near-crash risk by 2.5 times. Because of this heightened risk and clear negligence, insurance carriers tend to treat distracted driving accidents as higher-value claims.

Industry data and real case outcomes show that when distraction is proven, settlements are significantly higher than non-distraction claims, with many New York distracted driving settlements exceeding $1 million where injuries were serious.

‍

What You Need to Prove in a Distracted Driving Accident Case

To win a distracted driving case in New York, you must prove four things:

1. ‍Duty of care: The driver had a duty to operate the vehicle safely.
2. ‍Breach of duty: The driver breached that duty.
3. ‍Causation: The distraction caused the crash. This behavior must be connected to the collision.
4. ‍Damages: Pain and suffering, medical bills, lost earnings, and property damage.

These elements are straightforward in theory but difficult to prove in practice unless you have a skilled car accident lawyer specializing in distracted driving by your side.

Especially when a driver denies distraction or the insurer disputes causation, strong evidence becomes the deciding factor of the compensation you receive for your car accident.

‍

Legal Strategies to Recover Maximum Compensation

An experienced distracted driving car accident lawyer in New York knows exactly how to build a strong negligence case to counter insurance company tactics.

Car accident attorneys apply the following strategies to strengthen distracted driving claims, thereby increasing the settlement value for injured victims in New York:

‍1. Establish negligence

A distracted driver accident lawyer’s first job is to show that the at-fault driver failed to pay attention, thereby causing the crash. When distraction is proved with evidence such as phone records, GPS activity, or app usage logs, this directly increases case value under New York personal injury law.

2. Reducing comparative fault

The insurance company will try to argue that you were partially responsible via New York’s comparative negligence rule even if you were not wrong. On such occasions, your car accident lawyer in distracted driving will use accident reconstruction, expert testimony, and more evidence to push that percentage down to zero or as low as possible for a higher payout.

3. Weakening the insurer’s defense

When distraction is proven, the insurer has a weaker defense since liability becomes clearer. This will cause greater pressure to settle for a fair amount. Therefore, experienced accident lawyers in New York use documented distracted driving claims to force the insurer to reconsider lowball offers.

4. Using punitive damages to negotiate

Reckless behavior like texting while driving creates leverage similar to punitive exposure. Although suing for punitive damages is rare in NY auto cases, insurers know how juries dislike distracted drivers, and this fear leads them to increase settlement value.

A distracted driving accident lawyer who advocates for their clients builds well-supported distracted driving cases that force insurers to respond better with faster negotiations and higher settlement discussions since the court decision will rarely be favorable for the at-fault driver who chose to be careless.

For Further Reading:

NYC Distracted Driver Accident Lawyer vs. Insurance Companies: What to Know

New York Car Accident Lawyer Distracted Driving Cases: How Digital Evidence Proves Fault

‍